Table 3.

Numberz of sycamore roots (> 5 mm [0.3 in] diameter) occurring at different depths adjacent to sidewalks with various root barriers in two soil types. Percentage of sycamore roots (> 5 mm [0.3 in] diameter) occurring at different depths is indicated in parentheses.

Depth from soil surfaceNo barrierBiobarrier™Deep Root™GravelPolyethylene
Well-drained soil
≤10 cm34 by (50)34 b (48.6)17 b (35.4)0 a (0)22 b (39.3)
≥ 10–30 cm34 a (50)36 a (51.4)31 a (64.6)23 a (100)34 a (60.7)
Total number68 b70 b48 b23 a56 b
Poorly drained soil
≤10 cm42 b (29)11 a (15.3)38 b (45.8)15 a (16.8)20 ab (20.8)
≥ 10–30 cm103 a (71)61 a (84.7)45 a (54.2)74 a (83.2)76 a (79.2)
Total number145 b72 a83 a89 a96 a
Statistical significance
TreatmentsP < 0.05
Soil typeP < 0.05
Treatments × soil typeP < 0.04
  • z Means were calculated on four tree–sidewalk pairs per treatment. Sidewalks were 10 cm (4 in) thick.

  • y Numbers in a row and within a soil drainage type with different letters indicate significant difference at P < 0.05 with Duncan’s MRT.