Table 2.

Force to failure by direction for each tree stabilization system.

Stabilization system (direction)Mean forcez (kg [lb])CVy (σ/μ)
Brooks Tree Brace® (2)261.5 (575.3) ax0.28
Terra Toggle™ (1)247.5 (544.5) ab0.15
Terra Toggle™ (2)225.4 (495.9) ab0.24
2 × 2’s (1)212.6 (467.8) ab0.27
Rebar and ArborTie® (2)193.7 (426.2) abc0.43
Brooks Tree Brace® (1)164.7 (362.4) abcd0.12
Duckbill® (2)159.0 (349.8) abcd0.22
2 × 2’s (2)150.1 (330.2) bcde0.52
Duckbill® (1)101.2 (222.6) cdef0.20
ArborBrace® (1)  99.9 (219.8) cdef0.18
ArborBrace® (2)  99.5 (218.9) cdef0.48
Rebar and ArborTie® (1)  94.2 (207.2) cdef0.14
Tree Staple™ (2)  86.3 (189.9) def0.28
Wood dowels (1)  62.0 (136.3) def0.12
Wood dowels (2)  61.1 (134.4) ef0.34
T-stakes (2)  50.5 (111.1) f0.18
T-stakes (1)  50.4 (110.9) f0.19
Tree Staple™ (1)  48.1 (105.9) f0.13
Control  29.6 (65.1) f0.22
  • zAverage of one pulling direction (n = 5), except the control (n = 10).

  • yCoefficient of variation: standard deviation/mean.

  • xMeans with the same letter are not significantly different (P ≤ 0.05, Duncan’s multiple range test).