Table 3.

Percentage of species healthy and severely damaged along nonpaved roads treated and nontreated with MgCl2-based dust suppression products in Grand and Larimer Counties, Colorado.z

Healthy vegetation cover (%)Severely damaged vegetation cover (%)
Nontreated roadsTreated roadsNontreated roadsTreated roads
All vegetation combined89.278.3***  4.0  7.6***
Abies lasiocarpa99.287.8  0.8  4.3
Acer glabrum79.269.519.730.3
Alnus spp.73.975.310.519.3
Artemesia tridentata98.198.7  1.1  1.3
Chrysothamnus spp.68.689.1*  0.0  6.3
Juniperus scopulorum95.462.3**  0.6  1.9
Pinus contorta65.958.7*  6.213.3**
Pinus flexilus49.858.6  1.117.3
Picea engelmannii94.875.4***  2.5  3.1
Pinus ponderosa98.069.2***  0.0  5.4***
Populus angustifolia98.368.4  0.1  6.5
Populus tremuloides85.074.1***  7.412.3**
Pseudotsuga menzeisii95.393.7  2.0  5.7
Salix spp.80.371.9*  7.611.8
  • zLevels of significance are between road treatments for healthy and severely damaged vegetation.

  • ***P < 0.01,

  • **P < 0.05,

  • *P < 0.10 between percent healthy and severely damaged cover between road treatments.