Table 4.

Mean, standard errors of the means, and Tukey’s HSD post hoc tests for soil properties by treatment. Abbreviations: gravimetric soil moisture = GSM, water aggregate stability = WAS, electrical conductivity = EC, cation exchange capacity = CEC, calcium = Ca, magnesium = Mg, sodium = Na, potassium = K, phosphorus = P, nitrogen = N, carbon = C, soil organic matter = SOM, dissolved organic carbon = DOC, particulate organic matter = POM, microbial biomass carbon = MBC, respiration = RES, metabolic quotient = qCO2, soil quality index = SQI, null = N, tillage = T, fertilization + tillage = FT, biochar + tillage = BT, and biochar + fertilization + tillage = BFT.

PropertyNTFTBTBFT
MeanSEMeanSEMeanSEMeanSEMeanSE
GSM17.20.916.20.816.30.517.30.716.50.5
WAS59.62.460.01.861.72.155.52.261.52.2
pH7.690.107.720.097.720.107.740.097.620.09
EC201.722.8200.926.7200.913.2241.441.4223.230.4
CEC24.81.124.40.824.91.423.70.623.10.3
Ca3337216328614732522253160135301972
Mg6692468128710436542567425
Na4999343674534804787546477
K17941664172316751786
P13.00.913.01.115.42.114.81.713.60.9
N0.1680.0090.1570.0070.1730.0090.1610.0090.1810.009
C3.490.183.420.143.430.163.740.153.880.19
C/N22.20.923.11.021.20.924.80.923.01.2
SOM*5.63ab**0.165.29b0.165.49ab0.145.84ab0.156.00a0.13
DOC52.71.654.21.654.01.852.71.253.81.7
POM*7.53ab0.907.23b0.657.89ab0.779.61ab0.649.73a0.72
MBC2191420411196121881121613
RES12610120101138124131138
qCO20.02610.00200.02490.00150.03690.01200.02840.00250.02360.0015
SQI*64.9ab2.260.8b2.264.1ab2.263.6ab2.370.2a2.3
  • *Significant (P ≤ 0.05) difference with the post-hoc test.

  • **Letters represent means separation by Tukey’s Honest Significant Difference test.