Table 1.

Tolerances (and injury index scores) of 32 urban-tree cultivars to ozone (O3) and sulfur dioxide (SO2), alone and in combination, as determined by chamber tests and to ambient oxidants (primarily ozone) as determined by field tests. The field exposure ratings are based on 3 years of field observations on the cultivars growing at 4 test sites in the greater New York City area.

SpeciesCultivarTolerance1 (Injury index score) based on
Chamber exposures to:Field exposure to oxidants
O3SO2O3 + SO2oxidants
Acer platanoidesClevelandR(0)R(2)R(0)R
Crimson KingR(0)R(0)R(0)R
Crimson SentryR(0)I(12)R(1)R
ColumnarR(1)R(1)R)1)R
Emerald QueenR(10)R(0)R(1)R
Jade GlenR(9)R(2)R(2)R
SchwedlerI(12)R(4)I(12)R
SummershadeR(0)R(0)R(0)R
Acer rubrumAutumn FlameR(0)R(0)R(0)R
BowhallI(15)R(1)S(64)R
Red SunsetR(0)R(1)R(0)R
TilfordR(2)S(54)R(2)R
Acer saccharumGoldspireR(2)R(0)S(68)R
Green MountainR(0)R(0)R(8)R
Temple’s UprightR(0)R(0)R(0)R
Fagus sylvaticaRotundifoliaR(0)R(0)R(0)R
Fraxinus americanaAutumn PurpleS(62)S(183)S(39)R
Fraxinus excelsiorHesseiI(15)S(109)I(20)R
Fraxinus pennsylvanicaMarshall’s SeedlessI(13)S(112)S(44)I
SummitR(2)R(2)R(3)R
Ginkgo bilobaAutumn GoldR(0)I(14)R(2)R
FairmontR(0)R(1)I(14)R
FastigiateR(0)R(3)R(1)R
SentryR(0)R(0)R(0)R
Gleditsia triacanthos inermisEmerald LaceS(115)R(6)R(8)R
ImperialS(88)R(0)R(0)S
MajesticS(80)S(104)R(0)R
ShademasterS(76)R(0)R(1)I
SkylineS(41)S(54)R(1)R
SunburstS(49)S(97)R(1)I
Platanus acerifoliaBloodgoodS(137)S(54)S(146)S
Quercus roburFastigiateS(32)R(0)R(1)I
  • 1 S=sensitive, I=intermediate, R=tolerant